Sandy Hook

Sandy Hook
Showing posts with label Karen Handel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Karen Handel. Show all posts

Thursday, February 09, 2012

Susan G. Komen Foundation: The Fallout That Just Keeps Falling Out and Handel as the Sacrificial Lamb (2)

Oftentimes after a major development, I wait until the smoke settles before sifting through the ashes to uncover where the blaze started, but the raging forest fire that began with the Susan G. Komen Foundation's (SGK) decision to stop funding Planned Parenthood Federation of America (PPFA) can't be contained. This is due in large measure to SGK's own founder and CEO Nancy G. Brinker who has flamed the fires every time she's opened her mouth. Duplicity, hypocrisy and lies do have a tendency to blow up in one's face, leaving a firestorm of gigantic proportions in its wake.
This is the lead paragraph from when I started writing this piece a couple of days ago, but at this point, any fuel I might add to the fire would just be anticlimactic and more than a little redundant. There are a few issues, however, that are important enough (at least to me) to bear repeating, not the least of which is SGK's tilt toward the right-to-life-until-birth belief, which has in fact been driving this organization for some years now.

Anytime a huge corporatist charity with total revenues of $357,832,083 (and which compensates its CEO to the tune of $417,171) catches its pants on fire, charitable minded souls grab their shovels and start digging. For the past week, the Internet has been a veritable goldmine of revelations about the Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation, which became the Susan G. Komen Race for the Cure when it changed and trademarked its name in 2007. So, besides providing $680,000 in grant monies to PPFA for breast health services, SGK spends over a million bucks a year suing lesser known charities for trademark infringement.
So far, Komen has identified and filed legal trademark oppositions against more than a hundred of these Mom and Pop charities, including Kites for a Cure, Par for The Cure, Surfing for a Cure and Cupcakes for a Cure--and many of the organizations are too small and underfunded to hold their ground.
Excuses, Excuses

The first excuse CEO Brinker gave for slashing PPFA behind the knees in a sneak attack with a machete was that the foundation's "new" rules prevented providing grant monies to organizations that were under federal investigation. The sheer hypocrisy of this flimflam excuse is highlighted by Daily Kos:
The most obvious grant that highlighted Komen's hypocrisy was the $7.5 million to Penn State (Penn State is under federal investigation for its role in a sexual abuse scandal). Others were just as embarrassing. Days before the Komen scandal erupted, the USDA announced it launched an investigation into Harvard's treatment of primates in its research labs. The Education Department had just announced an investigation into whether Harvard discriminated against Asian-Americans in its undergraduate admissions policies. Meanwhile, two members of Komen's prestigious Scientific Advisory Board work at Harvard, while Harvard Medical School and the affiliated Dana-Farber Cancer Institute received over a million dollars in Komen funding.
From Komen-funded hospitals being investigated for Medicare fraud (example) to Komen-funded universities being investigated for civil rights violations, it became immediately apparent that the "local, state or federal investigation" prohibition cast a shadow over a substantial portion of Komen's good work. Within hours of the scandal breaking, it was clear Komen needed a new excuse.
And Brinker managed to contrive a couple of more disingenuous excuses when she appeared on MSNBC's "Andrea Mitchell Reports" and "proclaimed that the real reason Komen cut off almost all grants to Planned Parenthood was because 'many of the grants were education-oriented. We don't need to do that kind of education anymore' (watch the video here)."
As if that wasn't flimmmy-flammy enough, Brinker added:
“It was nothing they were doing wrong,” Brinker said of Planned Parenthood. “We have decided not to fund, wherever possible, pass-through grants. We were giving them money; they were sending women out for mammograms. What we would like to have are clinics where we can directly fund mammograms.”
Well now, I've yet to have a doctor feel my boobies and then walk me into an adjacent room for a mammography. I've always been referred to a breast center for an appointment, usually within a hospital, that specializes in and has the expensive equipment required to photograph the deepest recesses of my bosooms.

The absurdity of Brinker's claims are proven by Georgia Logothetis in this same article for Daily Kos. She took the most recent filings with the IRS and "put the grant data from both Komen's Parent and Group filings into public spreadsheets here and here. The classifications of "education," "treatment," "research" and "screening" are Komen's own grant classifications."

This morning, the Washington Post printed a letter from Nancy Brinker where she apologized and admitted, "I have made some mistakes." You have indeed, Mrs. Brinker but you've lost all credibility at this point.

So, Who Lit the First Spark?

If you're thinking the dreadful Karen Handel, you're thinking only partly right. Yes, she is indeed dreadful, but no, she didn't start the fire. In Part 1, I wrote:
As in all non-profit organizations, the board of directors exists to oversee and direct its operations. Nothing, absolutely nothing happens, without their approval and the approval of its CEO, who in this case just happens to be its founder Nancy G. Brinker.
Handel has resigned as Senior Vice President for Public Policy but she never should have been hired in the first place - a decision that was made on the part of Brinker and the board. No doubt, Handel's campaign promise to defund Planned Parenthood as she ran for (and lost) the governorship of Georgia was very attractive to Brinker, who is herself a devoted pro-life-until-birth advocate.

Brinker has given big bucks "to Republican candidates and committees, including anti-abortion politicians such as President George W. Bush and House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, R-Va., according to Federal Election Commission records."

Before there was a Karen Handel, there was Eve Sanchez Silver, a charter member of The Susan G. Komen Breast Cancer Foundation's National Hispanic/Latina Advisory Council. Silver resigned in 2004 when she learned that "some of SGK's local chapters gave money to PPFA affiliates to pay for breast exams for low-income women."
“You cannot be a life-affirming organization in league with an organization that kills people,” Silver said.
What this right-to-life-until-birth nonentity is really saying is that fetuses must be protected so that women, poor or otherwise, can die from breast cancer later in life. After leaving Komen, Silver's new mission became putting pressure on Komen to defund Planned Parenthood, which she and her minions did with gusto over the years - in part by threatening to boycott the events and to stop frequenting the businesses that sponsor them.

When Stearns began his bogus investigation last September, this paved the way for abortion opponents to increase their pressure on SGK. It also offered Handel a golden opportunity but she no doubt had help in board member Jane Abraham.
. . . Komen board member Jane Abraham is anti-choice. She is also the general chairman of the Susan B. Anthony list, a group known for their anti-choice stance as well as their influence within the Republican party. Abraham helps direct the Nurturing Network, a global network of pregnancy crisis centers famous for spreading false medical information and using coercion and intimidation to force women not to undergo abortions. Maureen Scalia, wife of rabidly anti-choice supreme court justice, Anthony Scalia, is also on the board of Nurturing Network.
The bottom line is that SGK had been bowing to and actively courting the pro-life-until-death forces for years. While it may have been Handel's proposal to insert a "new" rule denying grant monies to organizations that were under federal investigation, it was the CEO and the board of directors who approved it.

You know what is really amazing - and very telling - to me? Brinker has been quoted time and again as being "stunned" by the reaction from the media, politicians and Planned Parenthood supporters. She was "stunned?" Just how insular can a person be?

If the foundation ever hopes to polish its tarnished reputation, they need to clean house - starting at the top and working across the board.

Thursday, February 02, 2012

Susan G. Komen Foundation: Is There a Cure for Its Brand of Cancer? (1)

Whew! I don't think in their wildest imaginations a team of the best script writers in the world could have dreamed up such a plot. Mind boggling stupidity and political suicide combine to create a major public relations nightmare of gigantic proportions. In a scene spanning just a few hours, the Susan G. Komen Foundation (SGK) went from wearing pink ribbons to wrapping itself in black shrouds. I've never seen cancer spread so fast.

Enter the Americans United for Life (AUL) - until birth - which has been pressuring SGK to sever their ties with the Planned Parenthood Federation of America (PPFA) because of all those abortions they perform - a whopping three percent of their total services. The fact is, PPFA devotes most of its money and manpower to screening for breast, cervical and testicular cancers, treating menopause, testing for and treating sexually transmitted diseases, and providing contraception and prenatal care.
The money provided by Susan G. Komen for the Cure went to just a fraction -- about 19 according to one report -- of Planned Parenthood's more than 85 affiliates. And it was all -- roughly $680,000 last year and $580,000 the year before that -- used for breast-cancer screening and other breast-health services for low-income, uninsured, and under-insured women.
Last September, Rep. Cliff Stearns, bowing to right-to-life-until-birth lobbying efforts, launched his spurious investigation of PPFA to determine whether public money had been spent on abortions over the last decade.

Interestingly, this investigation just happened to coincide with a brand spanking new rule at SGK which forbids them from donating to any organization that is under local, state or federal investigation. Smell anything yet?

Then the fates (or was it God's will) intervened on behalf of those right-to-life-until-birth folks in the person of Karen Handel, SGK's new (as of April 2011) Senior Vice President for Public Policy. Writes Erin Gloria Ryan at Jezebel:
Karen Handel, who was endorsed by Sarah Palin during her unsuccessful bid for governor of Georgia in 2010, has been the Foundation's Senior Vice President for Public Policy since April 2011. During her gubernatorial candidacy, she ran on an anti-choice platform, vowing that if elected, she'd defund Planned Parenthood. Handel wrote on her campaign blog,

"I will be a pro-life governor who will work tirelessly to promote a culture of life in Georgia…. I believe that each and every unborn child has inherent dignity, that every abortion is a tragedy, and that government has a role, along with the faith community, in encouraging women to choose life in even the most difficult of circumstances…. since I am pro-life, I do not support the mission of Planned Parenthood."
She even promised to eliminate funding for breast and cervical cancer screenings provided by the organization.
Obviously, the confluence of the AUL, Stearns' specious investigation and the hiring of Handel just didn't happen by happenstance. Nope. As in all non-profit organizations, the board of directors exists to oversee and direct its operations. Nothing, absolutely nothing happens, without their approval and the approval of its CEO, who in this case just happens to be its founder Nancy G. Brinker.

The reaction to Komen's announcement that they were severing their not-too-cozy ties with Planned Parenthood was swift and it was angry and it was loud - a public relations disaster for SGK and a boon for PPFA. The Susan G. Komen Foundation, which cannot be distinguished from the Race for the Cure, shot itself in one foot with a double-barrel shotgun with this decision and then shot itself in the other by lying, further damaging its credibility.

For how long is anyone's guess but I suspect no amount of damage control is ever going to win back the hearts and dollars of lost donors or attract a huge new donor base. There just aren't enough right-to-life-until-born believers to support them in the style to which they've grown accustomed.

Out of every evil comes some good, however. After the story broke early Tuesday evening, it went viral on Facebook and Twitter, proving that sometimes, at least, these social networks can produce a chain reaction that is both awesome and heartwarming.

Within 24 hours, donors had contributed $650,000 to Planned Parenthood, "nearly enough to replace last year's Komen funding." $400,000 was raised by more than 6,000 donors and donations are still coming in.
The group also launched a Breast Health Emergency Fund to ensure funding to affiliates that will lose their Komen grants. That fund received a $250,000 gift from the family foundation of Dallas philanthropist Lee Fikes and his wife, Amy.
Planned Parenthood allies flooded the Komen Facebook page and other online message boards to express their anger and frustration. Komen, in a lame attempt that is disingenuous at best, is offering up a menu of lies and deception to try to stem the criticism. But most folks are having none of it, including the president of the Connecticut chapter who expressed her dismay on its Facebook page.
Many commenters on Facebook have complained that Komen is scrubbing some of the more negative comments from its wall, but a spokesperson for Komen said the organization is only deleting the profane ones. 
"We have not and do not scrub negative comments from Facebook unless they include profanity," said Leslie Aun, vice president of communications for Komen. "There have been some serious misrepresentations of our position, which is unfortunate. The level of interest reflects the fact that people care deeply about breast cancer and women's health issues."
This, my friends, is just another lie, to which I and many others can attest.
The main sentiment among the thousands of people posting online seems to be that regardless of one's position on the issue of abortion, it is wrong to politicize women's health. According to a new Polipulse analysis of online conversations about the issue, only 26 percent of people believe Komen made the right decision. Nearly a quarter of the people who expressed criticism of Komen's decision online said they were going to pull their donations from Komen.
Like Southern Beale in her rant Take Your Pink Ribbon & Shove It, I have no words but I share her anger toward SGK and the right-to-life-until-birth believers. "You’d rather grown, adult women die of undiagnosed breast cancer because a principle is more important than a person."  Also read her First They Came For Susan G. Komen . . . 

To quote my own comment after an excellent post at Progressive Eruptions:
Disgusted. Outraged. Pissed. None of these adjectives suffice.
Stay tuned. More to come.

UPDATE: As everyone, including blind, deaf and senile old Aunt Sally, probably knows, Nancy Brinker has apologized and said SGK will continue funding PPFA. Part 2, in an unintended change of direction, will look at the apology that isn't and why readers might be justified at feeling just a tad skeptical about Komen's sudden reversal.